Simple Smart Seminar
  • Stock
  • Investing
  • Politics
  • Tech News
  • Editor’s Pick
Editor's PickInvesting

Four Reasons School Choice Is Good, but Federal Is Bad

by May 13, 2025
May 13, 2025 0 comment

Neal McCluskey

A $5 billion scholarship tax credit is a part of the budget reconciliation bill just introduced in Congress. As a member of the Educational Freedom Supporters of America in good standing, few would doubt that I think school choice is an excellent thing. And I certainly understand the desire to take it nationwide via one big, beautiful, federal bill. But doing that would not ultimately be a beautiful thing, for four major reasons:

  1. It is unconstitutional: The Constitution gives the feds only specific, enumerated powers and all others are with the people or states. Education is nowhere among those powers, which means Washington has no authority to push school choice nationally, including through the tax code.
  2. It threatens one-stop shopping to regulate private education: Federal choice will start to get private schools nationwide connected to money associated with the federal government. A tax credit is not a voucher—money directly from the government—and is less prone to regulation, but it still carries rules. And more rules could be added as time goes on, including by future federal policymakers who like unionized workforces, student bathroom choice, or other policies many current choice supporters might not like. Leaving school choice to 50 different states diffuses the regulatory threat.
  3. The states are doing very well: Texas just passed a $1 billion school choice program, joining a huge choice boom in recent years and getting the country to the point where more than half of school-aged kids are eligible for private choice programs. Alas, some supporters of the federal tax credit have looked at this and lamented that some states, typically blue ones like New York, have not adopted choice, and they want an end run around those states. Connected to point number one, that would violate federalism—the feds do not get to bypass states just because some people dislike those states’ policies.
  4. The tax code is already complicated: We do not need yet another tax credit added to a highly complex federal tax code.

The good news is that there are some places where the federal government can, constitutionally, promote school choice: in Washington, DC itself, for military families, and for families served by the Bureau of Indian Education.

It should focus on those families and otherwise leave choice programs where they belong: the states.

0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
Trump hits Iran’s pocketbook as he dangles a carrot in Middle East speech
next post
Trump’s Afrikaner Refugees: Strange Process, Right Decision

You may also like

The Nation “Don’t Need No Doctor”: Rethinking the...

July 22, 2025

Young Workers Could Lose $110,000 in Lifetime Earnings...

July 22, 2025

Randomized Controlled Trials of Medicare and Medicaid, Please

July 21, 2025

China Shocked? Hard Hit Metropolitan Statistical Areas Have...

July 21, 2025

What Dr. Wen Gets Right—and Misses—About Teen Nicotine...

July 21, 2025

The Best Five Sectors, #28

July 20, 2025

Week Ahead: NIFTY Violates Short-Term Supports; Stays Tentative...

July 19, 2025

The Real Drivers of This Market: AI, Semis...

July 19, 2025

July Strength, Late-Summer Caution: 3 Charts to Watch

July 18, 2025

Three Stocks in Focus: One Old Favorite, One...

July 18, 2025

    Fill Out & Get More Relevant News


    Stay ahead of the market and unlock exclusive trading insights & timely news. We value your privacy - your information is secure, and you can unsubscribe anytime. Gain an edge with hand-picked trading opportunities, stay informed with market-moving updates, and learn from expert tips & strategies.

    Recent Posts

    • The Best Five Sectors, #28

      July 20, 2025
    • Week Ahead: NIFTY Violates Short-Term Supports; Stays Tentative Devoid Of Any Major Triggers

      July 19, 2025
    • The Real Drivers of This Market: AI, Semis & Robotics

      July 19, 2025
    • July Strength, Late-Summer Caution: 3 Charts to Watch

      July 18, 2025
    • Three Stocks in Focus: One Old Favorite, One Mag Name, and a Dow Comeback Story

      July 18, 2025
    • These HOT Industry Groups are Fueling This Secular Bull Market

      July 17, 2025
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 simplesmartseminar.com | All Rights Reserved

    Simple Smart Seminar
    • Stock
    • Investing
    • Politics
    • Tech News
    • Editor’s Pick