Simple Smart Seminar
  • Stock
  • Investing
  • Politics
  • Tech News
  • Editor’s Pick
Politics

Supreme Court Chief Justice Roberts reins in Sotomayor after repeated interruptions

by May 15, 2025
May 15, 2025 0 comment

Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts reined in Justice Sonia Sotomayor during argument over birthright citizenship and nationwide court injunctions on Thursday.

Sotomayor dominated questioning for several minutes at the outset of Thursday’s argument after taking over from Justice Clarence Thomas. She pressed U.S. Solicitor General John Sauer for President Donald Trump’s administration on several points relating to the authority for federal courts to issue nationwide injunctions, often speaking over the lawyer and interrupting him.

Sotomayor argued that Trump’s order invalidating birthright citizenship violated four Supreme Court precedents, and that it was justified for a federal judge to grant an injunction against such a controversial order.

‘You are claiming that not just the Supreme Court, that both the Supreme Court and no lower court, can stop an executive from universally violating holdings by this court,’ Sotomayor said.

‘We are not claiming that because we’re conceding that there could be an appropriate case only in class only,’ Sauer said.

‘But I hear that–,’ Sotomayor said, beginning to interrupt Sauer.

‘Can I hear the rest of his answer?’ Roberts then interjected.

Sauer then elaborated on his statement, saying the government is arguing that federal courts can intervene on behalf of specific plaintiffs before them, but not nationwide. He said the Supreme Court has the authority to grant nationwide injunctions in certain circumstances.

Sauer used the bulk of his opening arguments Thursday to reiterate the Trump administration’s view that universal injunctions exceeded lower courts’ Article III powers under the Constitution, noting that the injunctions ‘transgress the traditional bounds of equitable authority,’ and ‘create a host of practical problems.’

Universal injunctions ‘require judges to make rushed, high-stakes, low-information decisions,’ he said. ‘They operate asymmetrically, forcing the government to win everywhere,’ and ‘invert,’ in the administration’s view, the ordinary hierarchical hierarchy of appellate review. They create the ongoing risk of conflicting judgments.’

A Supreme Court decision here could have sweeping national implications, setting a precedent that would affect the more than 310 federal lawsuits that have challenged White House actions since Trump’s second presidency began on Jan. 20, 2025, according to a Fox News data analysis.

The consolidated cases before the court are Trump v. CASA, Trump v. the State of Washington, and Trump v. New Jersey.

It’s unclear when the justices will rule, but their decision to fast-track the case means an opinion or order could come within weeks – or even days.

Fox News’ Breanne Deppisch, Shannon Bream and Bill Mears contributed to this report.

This post appeared first on FOX NEWS
0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
Dems divided on Trump’s executive order aimed at slashing drug prices
next post
Trump makes historic UAE visit as first US president in nearly 20 years

You may also like

Homeless people can be removed from streets by...

July 24, 2025

GREGG JARRETT: Newly declassified documents destroy Russian collusion...

July 24, 2025

Ron Klain dodges reporters after marathon grilling in...

July 24, 2025

US and Israel urgently need to replenish weapons...

July 24, 2025

US pulls team from ceasefire talks in Qatar...

July 24, 2025

Ex-Biden chief of staff giving ‘credible’ answers in...

July 24, 2025

White House sends mixed signals in Russia ‘hoax’...

July 24, 2025

Hamas ‘hardens’ stance in ceasefire talks as Netanyahu...

July 24, 2025

Trump foe Boasberg orders DOJ to detail status...

July 24, 2025

Trump foe Boasberg to grill DOJ over migrant...

July 24, 2025

    Fill Out & Get More Relevant News


    Stay ahead of the market and unlock exclusive trading insights & timely news. We value your privacy - your information is secure, and you can unsubscribe anytime. Gain an edge with hand-picked trading opportunities, stay informed with market-moving updates, and learn from expert tips & strategies.

    Recent Posts

    • S&P 500 Breaking Out Again: What This Means for Your Portfolio

      July 24, 2025
    • Momentum Leaders Are Rotating — Here’s How to Find Them

      July 24, 2025
    • Is META Breaking Out or Breaking Down?

      July 23, 2025
    • A Wild Ride For the History Books: 2025 Mid-Year Recap

      July 23, 2025
    • Tech Taps the Brakes, Homebuilders Hit the Gas: See the Rotation on StockCharts Today

      July 22, 2025
    • The Best Five Sectors, #28

      July 20, 2025
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 simplesmartseminar.com | All Rights Reserved

    Simple Smart Seminar
    • Stock
    • Investing
    • Politics
    • Tech News
    • Editor’s Pick