Simple Smart Seminar
  • Stock
  • Investing
  • Politics
  • Tech News
  • Editor’s Pick
Editor's PickInvesting

A College Endowment Tax Is the Wrong Federal Policy

by May 20, 2025
May 20, 2025 0 comment

Neal McCluskey

An American flag waves in front of the Capitol with a stormy sky

To stick it to “woke, elite universities,” House Republicans have included a new tax on private college endowments in their “big, beautiful bill.” The rate would top out at 21 percent for endowments of at least $2 million per student. While endowment sizes can be unseemly—Harvard has a stash bigger than the GDP of most countries—the tax would be bad policy for several reasons.

First, the tax system should never be used to punish people based on their political opinions. But that is clearly what House Republicans are doing when they identify the targets of their tax as “woke.” Punishing ideological adversaries might not be their only motivation—they might want new revenue or think college endowments get sweetheart tax treatment—but it is unquestionably a motive.

Second, what about the sweetheart treatment possibility? That seems dubious, at least relative to how nonprofits generally are taxed.

I am not an expert on taxation, but it appears that non-university endowments, such as private foundations and nonoperating foundations, face nothing like a 21 percent net investment income tax, instead facing 1 to 2 percent taxes or 5 percent payout requirements, respectively. Unless I’m missing something, rich colleges would be getting much harsher treatment. And that is not the end of the targeting: Public universities, which have huge, direct government funding advantages over private institutions, would be exempted, as would religious institutions meeting certain criteria, including being founded after July 4, 1776. That puts a very small group of institutions—look at the years when Ivy League institutions were founded—in the crosshairs.

The beautiful bill would also raise net investment income taxes on some foundations, but the top rate would only be 10 percent for those with assets of $5 billion or more. And it, too, would violate the “no political punishment” rule I stated above, with committee Republicans saying explicitly that the target is “radical left-wing organizations in the tax-exempt sector.”

Third, endowments consist of money voluntarily given to schools by funders. That is what we should want in a free, diverse society. Meanwhile, the federal government cumulatively gives hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars to college students, which they eventually deliver to institutions and to higher ed-based researchers who often undertake wasteful or ineffective projects. What Congress should do is phase out this forced taxpayer funding, requiring the Ivory Tower to be built on voluntary giving. You know, like endowment funds.

If people want to give their own money to “woke, elite universities,” who is government to judge? Instead, it should worry about its own, forced funding of higher ed.

0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
GOP holdouts unmoved by Trump’s ‘big, beautiful’ trip to Capitol Hill
next post
S&P 500, Bitcoin & XLK: What the Charts Are Saying Now

You may also like

From Oversold to Opportunity: Small Caps on the...

July 3, 2025

Bank Capital Standards

July 3, 2025

Psychedelic Legalization

July 3, 2025

Freedom of Speech Is Worth Celebrating, as Europe...

July 3, 2025

Money’s Not Leaving the Market — It’s Rotating!

July 3, 2025

Expanding Federal Involvement in Education Isn’t the Way...

July 3, 2025

American Craft Brewers Suffering Under Trump’s Tariffs

July 3, 2025

More NYC Corruption

July 3, 2025

Trump’s “Unimpeachable” Reputation

July 3, 2025

53 Percent Don’t Know Why We Declared Independence...

July 3, 2025

    Fill Out & Get More Relevant News


    Stay ahead of the market and unlock exclusive trading insights & timely news. We value your privacy - your information is secure, and you can unsubscribe anytime. Gain an edge with hand-picked trading opportunities, stay informed with market-moving updates, and learn from expert tips & strategies.

    Recent Posts

    • From Oversold to Opportunity: Small Caps on the Move

      July 3, 2025
    • Money’s Not Leaving the Market — It’s Rotating!

      July 3, 2025
    • Missed Disney’s Rally? Grab This Defined-Risk Put Spread for a Second Chance

      July 2, 2025
    • Should You Buy Roblox Stock Now? Key Levels to Watch

      July 2, 2025
    • MACD Crossovers: Why Most Traders Get It Wrong

      July 2, 2025
    • Market Signals Align – Is a Bigger Move Ahead?

      July 2, 2025
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 simplesmartseminar.com | All Rights Reserved

    Simple Smart Seminar
    • Stock
    • Investing
    • Politics
    • Tech News
    • Editor’s Pick